YieldWell
Methodology

How we separate design skill from market luck

Every property return is two returns stacked together: the one the market handed every owner on the street, and the one the property itself earned. YieldWell’s job is to split them — in the open, with the arithmetic on this page.

The formula, end to end

Alpha = your CAGR − your market’s CAGR
Both measured over your exact hold period, in the same place.

Step 1 — Your return. Your compound annual growth rate (CAGR) comes from the two prices you report: CAGR = (sale price ÷ purchase price)1/years − 1, where years is your exact hold in days ÷ 365.25.

Step 2 — The market’s return. We compute the same CAGR for your local market index over the same period (data sources below). This is the return a completely untouched property in your market would be expected to track.

Step 3 — Alpha. Alpha is the difference, in percentage points per year. Positive alpha means your property outgrew its market; negative means the market outgrew your property.

Step 4 — Dollars. Expected sale price = purchase price × (1 + market CAGR)years. Differential revenue = your actual sale price − expected sale price. Differential profit = differential revenue − your total design and renovation spend. Return on reno = differential revenue ÷ renovation spend.

A fully worked example

One illustrative property, every step shown. A house bought in June 2015 for $600,000, renovated for $80,000, and sold in June 2020 for $920,000, in a market zone whose benchmark prices grew at 6.0%/yr over that period:

StepResult
Hold period5.0 years
Your CAGR — (920,000 ÷ 600,000)1/5 − 18.92%/yr
Market CAGR (zone benchmark, same months)6.00%/yr
Alpha — 8.92% − 6.00%+2.92 pts/yr
Expected sale at the market rate — 600,000 × 1.065$802,935
Differential revenue — 920,000 − 802,935$117,065
Less renovation spend− $80,000
Differential profit$37,065
Return on reno — 117,065 ÷ 80,000146%
S&P 500 total return, same hold (see below)15.22%/yr

The verdict sentence on the result reads: “The market gave you 6.0%. You created the other 2.9 points.” Note the honesty in this example: the S&P 500 beat this property. The comparators are not rigged in the homeowner’s favour.

Data sources

Canada — CREA market zones. Monthly benchmark price series for 60 Canadian market zones, January 2005 to the most recent published month. Your city is matched to a zone (some cities map to a neighbouring zone; if no city matches, we fall back to your province, then to a national aggregate — your result always says which level matched). Your buy and sell months are matched to the zone’s benchmark price at those months, and the market CAGR is (benchmarksell ÷ benchmarkbuy)1/years − 1 over your exact hold in days.

United States — FHFA House Price Index (ZIP5). The FHFA publishes annual price-change rates at ZIP-code level. Because that series is annual, the US market CAGR compounds the published annual changes for the full calendar years inside your hold (buy year + 1 through sell year) and annualizes over the year span. This is annual compounding by construction — a slightly coarser clock than Canada’s monthly series, and one reason cross-border alpha comparisons should be made with care.

Address resolution. Addresses are geocoded with OpenStreetMap/Nominatim to a city, province/state, and (in the US) ZIP code. Market data currently covers Canada and the US only.

The S&P 500 comparator

The third number on your result is the S&P 500’s total return — price change plus dividends reinvested — compounded over the full calendar years inside your hold: the returns for (buy year + 1) through (sell year), annualized. The annual series is the standard published S&P 500 total-return table (Slickcharts / DQYDJ reproductions of S&P Dow Jones Indices data), hardcoded for complete calendar years 1990–2024 so the calculation never depends on a live feed. If your hold contains no full calendar year — or extends past the table — we show a note instead of a number rather than annualize a partial year.

The percentile line

“Your property appreciated faster than X% of the N markets we track (same period)” compares your property’s CAGR against the CAGR of every tracked market over your identical period: all 60 Canadian zones, or every US ZIP code with a complete FHFA series for the period (scoped to your state when enough in-state ZIPs have data; the line always names its scope). It is a percentile of markets — never of designers, sellers, or other people’s projects — and it is labelled that way everywhere it appears, including share cards.

Self-reported vs. Verified Alpha

Self-reported Every result from the free tool today. We compute faithfully from the numbers you type, but we have not checked them. Self-reported results are labelled as such on screen and on share cards.

Verified Alpha Coming with YieldWell Pro. Verification will require the project’s address, purchase and sale dates, and prices to be matched against public sale records, with renovation spend supported by documentation. Only then is the Verified badge issued. A self-reported number never wears the verified label — the distinction is the product.

Limitations — read these

How YieldWell makes money

The calculator is free. YieldWell Pro — portfolio tracking and Verified Alpha for designers and renovators — is the paid product, currently in waitlist. We don’t charge homeowners, and a result page’s only calls to action are to share the result, verify it, or run another property.

Run your property →
Methodology last updated November 2026 · Data: CREA (CA), FHFA HPI (US), S&P 500 total return 1990–2024